You are standing in the spice aisle staring at two little jars of saffron. One costs twenty dollars and the other costs forty dollars. Both look the same to you. You pick up the cheaper one and wonder if you are about to waste your money on dyed grass clippings. That worry is common because saffron is the most faked spice in the pantry. It costs more per gram than silver, so counterfeiters have every reason to cheat you. Here is how to tell the real thing from the fake, step by step, without any special equipment.

CHATTY MONTHLY GOALS || JANUARY UPDATE + GOALS FOR FEBRUARY || My Weight Loss Journey

Start with the simplest test. Drop one thread into a glass of warm water. Do not stir it. Real saffron is shy about giving up its color. It releases its yellow and red pigments slowly over several minutes. The water will turn a pale golden shade and then deepen. A fake thread, on the other hand, stains the water almost the instant it hits the surface. If the water turns bright yellow or orange within seconds, you are holding dyed straw or colored corn silk. Put that jar back on the shelf.

Now look at the shape of the thread before you wet it. Real saffron is the dried stigma of the crocus flower, and it has a very specific anatomy. Hold the thread up to a window or a bright light. The real stigma flares at one end like a miniature trumpet. The other end is thinner and tapers off. No two threads look exactly alike. They vary in length, in curl, and in the depth of their red. Fake saffron, which is often made from shredded red-dyed corn silk or paper, looks too uniform. Every piece has the same size and shape. You will not spot a trumpet end anywhere.

You can also use your sense of smell. Real saffron has a scent that is hard to describe but easy to recognize once you know it. It smells like honey and dried hay with a metallic edge. Some people say it smells like the Mediterranean. The fake stuff usually has a sweet floral smell from cheap perfume or no smell at all. Rub a thread between your fingers. Real saffron leaves a little yellow oil on your skin. Fake saffron leaves nothing or a red dye stain.

Why does all this matter besides the money? The reason people buy saffron is not just for the color and taste in paella or risotto. The same compounds that give saffron its color and aroma are the ones that interest researchers. The two main compounds are called crocin and safranal. Crocin is the pigment. Safranal is the scent. These are the compounds that show up in supplements, usually at a much smaller dose than a recipe uses. A pinch of saffron in a dish gives you a tiny amount of these compounds. A supplement capsule might have even less.

If you are buying saffron for cooking, the test with warm water is all you need. Drop one thread in and watch. Real saffron threads will hold their red color even after the water turns yellow. Fake threads will turn pale or white because the cheap dye has left them. You can buy one small jar of good saffron and keep it in a dark cabinet for a year or more. It stays potent as long as it stays dry. The next time you are in that spice aisle, you will know exactly what to do. Pick up a jar, take out one thread, and if the store manager gives you a look, just say you are doing a science experiment.

For more on this, see cooking with saffron.

2

2